Moderator: Community Team
Dukasaur wrote:saxitoxin wrote:taking medical advice from this creature; a morbidly obese man who is 100% convinced he willed himself into becoming a woman.
Your obsession with mrswdk is really sad.
ConfederateSS wrote:Just because people are idiots... Doesn't make them wrong.
Loose Canon wrote:I reckon if a townie does not have a powerful role such as cop and not a weak vanilla role either but a role which can do something but not much, then it could be that a day1 claim of that role could be of benefit to town.
eg if I had the day 1 my vote doesn't count, day 2 vote counts double, day 3 vote doesn't count etc, role again, then again I would let that be known.
My thinking is;
Just don't think a mafia would go with a fake claim day1.
Therefore it would identify 1 player as town straight up, and therefore mafia at some point have to go for the player without a powerful role.
Up for discussion and I'm putting it out there because another townie might have such a role and might agree with me....?
Votanic wrote:Loose Canon wrote:I reckon if a townie does not have a powerful role such as cop and not a weak vanilla role either but a role which can do something but not much, then it could be that a day1 claim of that role could be of benefit to town.
eg if I had the day 1 my vote doesn't count, day 2 vote counts double, day 3 vote doesn't count etc, role again, then again I would let that be known.
My thinking is;
Just don't think a mafia would go with a fake claim day1.
Therefore it would identify 1 player as town straight up, and therefore mafia at some point have to go for the player without a powerful role.
Up for discussion and I'm putting it out there because another townie might have such a role and might agree with me....?
What the...?
I'll assume for a moment you are asking this as town... If so, please realize, there is no real benefit to this, LC.
...and my saying this doesn't just sound 'towny'. It is towny.
Anyone and everyone, scum included, can just give a fake, quasi-vanilla role (or really f*ck with everybody and just say 'vanilla' anyway).
This is the smartest thing to do if this tiresome madness gets forced down our throats...again.
However only dumb townies will actually give out real information about themselves at this point. Don't do it.
BTW, Role Madness doesn't automatically assume that Scum has any (extra) PRs.
Basic Mafia school of thought treats the normal scum abilities of team awareness and night kills as plenty of PR already.
However, the last two game mods thought it was clever and fun to give Scum extra PRs, so DDS might do that too. I don't know...
Town, instead of hoping to win the game by carelessly giving away info (or bullying others into declaring...).
Try to win by wisely using your comments, questions, votes and PRs... and remember your greatest PR will always be your own abilities of perception and deduction.
One other point: Yes, sometimes 'joke' votes are just meant as 'jokes' (except when they're not...) but since 'joke' votes are never actully funny jokes (unoriginal, played-out) let's all try to not waste each other's time by posting them. I'm not trying to be a kill-joy about jokes and humor, I'm just saying if you want to be a comedian, select original material with some degree of wit.
swang918 wrote:Re vot, eh Ive actually had the same thought as loose before. That in a role heavy game it might make sense to do like a mass claim early. Loose suggested it in the tick i think, got some heat there for it but I was scum in that game and I was kind of afraid of it. Forces scum to pick a fake claim early and if you get lucky then a scum fake claims a role that a town already has. Of course you have to weight this against exposing the cop early but the idea is that with many power roles, you make up for that
fusibaseball wrote:VOTE PMC
Dukasaur wrote:saxitoxin wrote:taking medical advice from this creature; a morbidly obese man who is 100% convinced he willed himself into becoming a woman.
Your obsession with mrswdk is really sad.
ConfederateSS wrote:Just because people are idiots... Doesn't make them wrong.
kongming3 wrote:Just caught up on all the posts and figuring out how I should be playing this. I did in fact appreciate the joke charles so I shan't fuss about the vote against me.
swang918 wrote:Re vot, eh Ive actually had the same thought as loose before. That in a role heavy game it might make sense to do like a mass claim early. Loose suggested it in the tick i think, got some heat there for it but I was scum in that game and I was kind of afraid of it. Forces scum to pick a fake claim early and if you get lucky then a scum fake claims a role that a town already has. Of course you have to weight this against exposing the cop early but the idea is that with many power roles, you make up for that
strike wolf wrote:Extreme Ways wrote:Charle wrote:Kong, you only wanted to know who your fellow partners are and then left? We need to get this in some kind of direction. I guess, first day is just fooling around until we have N1 results.
Vote Kong
So by the way, can circumcisions be carried out at any age, or is there a cutoff date?
I was surprised everybody else was still fluffposting and ignored this thh
Sad that he has withdrawn it was a great discussion point. Probably dropped it
Also not convinced by PMC needing to emphasise his towniness
Eh. I agree with PMC that if anything it indicates more that he is not mafia than anything as mafia would know their scummates. I think you could say if he later turns up mafia that Vot and PMC (and I guess myself) are more likely to be his scummates but for now, I am leaning against the statement meaning anything scummy.
Loose Canon wrote:Not obvious kong is town Charle. I played the wolves don't know who the other wolves are till N1 line in millars hollow remember.
Loose Canon wrote:I reckon if a townie does not have a powerful role such as cop and not a weak vanilla role either but a role which can do something but not much, then it could be that a day1 claim of that role could be of benefit to town.
eg if I had the day 1 my vote doesn't count, day 2 vote counts double, day 3 vote doesn't count etc, role again, then again I would let that be known.
My thinking is;
Just don't think a mafia would go with a fake claim day1.
Therefore it would identify 1 player as town straight up, and therefore mafia at some point have to go for the player without a powerful role.
Up for discussion and I'm putting it out there because another townie might have such a role and might agree with me....?
pmchugh wrote:swang918 wrote:Re vot, eh Ive actually had the same thought as loose before. That in a role heavy game it might make sense to do like a mass claim early. Loose suggested it in the tick i think, got some heat there for it but I was scum in that game and I was kind of afraid of it. Forces scum to pick a fake claim early and if you get lucky then a scum fake claims a role that a town already has. Of course you have to weight this against exposing the cop early but the idea is that with many power roles, you make up for that
I agree that as mafia it's super annoying to face mass claims, but honestly it's not really playing the game to me. Some rule sets even ban it, or have anti claim mechanisms, like giving extra kill if you can guess the role. I am more interested in seeing town progress in this game from last one, and try to figure it out from the posts, even if it is debatably better to use more claims early.
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users