Random Map / Random Map settings

by **s3xt0y** on Sat May 23, 2009 12:58 pm

Concise description:

Random map/map settings setting. Ok, so basically you will start a game called random, which you can only specifiy the number of players as a game option. Then once the game has started the settings will be shown and map will be chosen **NOT DURING THE JOIN STAGE**

Specifics:

Have the regular 1-8 player games
Team games could be selected if desired

This will improve the following aspects of the site:

Would be a fun element forcing users to use all of the maps available on the site.
Would be more difficult to be a map specific player
...feel free to add

s3x

by **kcoenich** on Sat May 23, 2009 2:15 pm

ja jaja, well... nice idea. I think it would need to show if the game is standard or doubles, triples or cuadruples... there are lots of people that like that kind of games, and maybe they dont join just because they dont see what tipe of game is it. in general I like it...

by **Woodruff** on Sat May 23, 2009 3:27 pm

s3xt0y wrote:Concise description:
Random map/map settings setting. Ok, so basically you will start a game called random, which you can only specifiy the number of players as a game option. Then once the game has started the settings will be shown and map will be chosen **NOT DURING THE JOIN STAGE**

Specifics:
Have the regular 1-8 player games
Team games could be selected if desired

This will improve the following aspects of the site:
Would be a fun element forcing users to use all of the maps available on the site.
Would be more difficult to be a map specific player
...feel free to add

s3x

I like the idea of a "random map" a LOT. In fact, it's the very basis of most of the tournaments that I run.

But I personally would NEVER want to be forced into, for instance, a freestyle game.

So maybe if it could be set up so that "anything not selected would be randomly determined"...that way, I can still specify that it will be a sequential game or a standard game or a doubles game...but then anything I didn't specify would be randomized. I think this would be a tremendous addition to the site, personally.

by **lozzini** on Sat May 23, 2009 4:38 pm

s3xt0y wrote:Concise description:
Random map/map settings setting. Ok, so basically you will start a game called random, which you can only specifiy the number of players as a game option. Then once the game has started the settings will be shown and map will be chosen **NOT DURING THE JOIN STAGE**

Specifics:
Have the regular 1-8 player games
Team games could be selected if desired

This will improve the following aspects of the site:
Would be a fun element forcing users to use all of the maps available on the site.
Would be more difficult to be a map specific player
...feel free to add

s3x

i think this is a great idea. However i believe that random should be a option for every setting avaiable

e.g. forts - adh, unlim, chained, random

so people could specify game type and seq play for example whilst still having random cards map and fog

lozz

by **s3xt0y** on Sat May 23, 2009 11:05 pm

I like what you guys have to say, and i agree with all of you. That was kinda what i was going for, an option to add in the random element to everything or just some specific map aspects.

s3x

by **Megadeth666** on Sun May 24, 2009 6:29 am

Very Good Idea

by **Beinion** on Sun May 24, 2009 7:31 am

great idea! I love it

by **Rocketry** on Sun May 24, 2009 8:25 am

Excellent idea! Random map, weather, cards ... hmm some people might not like the chance of having to play freestyle. Perhaps not include that bit? So you would select number of players, doubles, assassin... whatever ... seq/free and then random the rest.

Rocekt.

by **s3xt0y** on Sun May 24, 2009 8:27 am

A random option attached to each and every variable in the game could be added which would be smarter than just an overall completely random game.

s3x

by **4myGod** on Sun May 24, 2009 9:56 am

I would be worried though that many people wouldn't completely think through the decision. They might see a game with random cards for example, but not completely think out what the options are for cards. So they join, then it falls on No Cards and they think "oh crap, I didn't even know that was an option" and they ignore the game perhaps. I guess this would mainly be for new players who didn't care about losing rank and just as well didn't know what the game types were.

What do you guys think? This could be a problem?

by **s3xt0y** on Sun May 24, 2009 10:52 am

Well the people here that would deadbeat on games, would anyway I don't see too many people just leaving their game because it has no cards. If I were to join a random game I would be expecting the worst not the best, because if I wanted to play something I was comfortable with / everyone playing was comfortable then I would create a game with no randomness.

s3x

by **lozzini** on Sun May 24, 2009 11:32 am

4myGod wrote:I would be worried though that many people wouldn't completely think through the decision. They might see a game with random cards for example, but not completely think out what the options are for cards. So they join, then it falls on No Cards and they think "oh crap, I didn't even know that was an option" and they ignore the game perhaps. I guess this would mainly be for new players who didn't care about losing rank and just as well didn't know what the game types were.

What do you guys think? This could be a problem?

random settings could be stopped for new recruits same as complicated maps are atm i believe

by **AndyDufresne** on Sun May 24, 2009 7:07 pm

I'd like both honestly.

--Andy

by **Timminz** on Sun May 24, 2009 7:10 pm

Couldn't this idea be extended to any of the settings? When creating a game, you can pick whichever settings you want for sure, and set the rest to random.

by **Woodruff** on Mon May 25, 2009 4:17 am

Another option needs to be added to the poll: "Anything not selected is randomized"

by **s3xt0y** on Mon May 25, 2009 8:21 am

done and done sir

s3x

by **lozzini** on Mon May 25, 2009 9:17 am

anyt think anythink not selected randomized would be better worded as option for randomizing any setting... just me being picky though... some people might get confused...

by **Rocketry** on Mon May 25, 2009 10:50 am

Timminz wrote:Couldn't this idea be extended to any of the settings? When creating a game, you can pick whichever settings you want for sure, and set the rest to random.

Oooh you got it! Select all the things you want to control. Hit random and watch it fill in the rest. Perfect!

Blocking new recruits makes some sense. They should be allowed to join randomised games, just not create them. (Unless, of course, the game randomised to a setting that was already blocked for new recruuits eg Freestyle AoR.)

Rocket.

by **lozzini** on Mon May 25, 2009 10:55 am

Rocketry wrote:
Timminz wrote:Couldn't this idea be extended to any of the settings? When creating a game, you can pick whichever settings you want for sure, and set the rest to random.

Oooh you got it! Select all the things you want to control. Hit random and watch it fill in the rest. Perfect!

Blocking new recruits makes some sense. They should be allowed to join randomised games, just not create them. (Unless, of course, the game randomised to a setting that was already blocked for new recruuits eg Freestyle AoR.)

Rocket.

i think the suggestion is that you don't know what random settings were selected until after the game starts... so not only the creator but the other players do not know what the game will be when they join

lozz

by **s3xt0y** on Mon May 25, 2009 6:54 pm

lozzini wrote:
Rocketry wrote:
Timminz wrote:Couldn't this idea be extended to any of the settings? When creating a game, you can pick whichever settings you want for sure, and set the rest to random.

Oooh you got it! Select all the things you want to control. Hit random and watch it fill in the rest. Perfect!

Blocking new recruits makes some sense. They should be allowed to join randomised games, just not create them. (Unless, of course, the game randomised to a setting that was already blocked for new recruuits eg Freestyle AoR.)

Rocket.

i think the suggestion is that you don't know what random settings were selected until after the game starts... so not only the creator but the other players do not know what the game will be when they join

lozz

This is correct!

s3x

by **s3xt0y** on Wed May 27, 2009 3:40 pm

So how does one go about making this idea a reality ?

s3x

by **lozzini** on Wed May 27, 2009 3:45 pm

s3xt0y wrote:So how does one go about making this idea a reality ?

s3x

Keep gaining community support until you attract the attention of a mod... then maybe a senior member of the CC team... then let it sit on the to do list for several years... then voila

lozz

by **Megadeth666** on Wed May 27, 2009 4:10 pm

RANDOM RANDOM

ALMOST LIKE MOST TOURNEYS WE JOIN....JUST FUN, AND YOU WILL NEVER KNOW WHO WILL WIN........AWESOME IDEA

by **AndyDufresne** on Wed May 27, 2009 4:23 pm

lozzini wrote:
s3xt0y wrote:So how does one go about making this idea a reality ?

s3x

Keep gaining community support until you attract the attention of a mod... then maybe a senior member of the CC team... then let it sit on the to do list for several years... then voila

lozz

Hopefully it will be shorter than that.

At least part of the suggestion...

--Andy

by **lozzini** on Wed May 27, 2009 4:27 pm

AndyDufresne wrote:
lozzini wrote:
s3xt0y wrote:So how does one go about making this idea a reality ?

s3x

Keep gaining community support until you attract the attention of a mod... then maybe a senior member of the CC team... then let it sit on the to do list for several years... then voila

lozz

Hopefully it will be shorter than that. At least part of the suggestion...

--Andy

see look it's all about gaining attention

cheers andy for the update

Random Map / Random Map settings

Would you enter into a game with random settings?

Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Re: Random Map / Random Map settings

Who is online