[OFFICIAL] Charle's Fun Mafia - "Game On" Day 4

by **Extreme Ways** on Thu Oct 02, 2025 1:52 pm

SoN!c wrote:
Loose Canon wrote:Its fine as far as I'm concerned, and the modkill on me is fine - if that's what happened.

Accidents happen out of good intentions.

I take responsibility.

I think I drove the in game lynch on Town Extreme too, and if anyone wants to blame me for the in game lynch on Town Max I do wear that badge as well.

The pleasure of the game for me is in playing it and immersing yourself in the intricacies whilst having a bit of lighthearted fun and I particularly hope the new players felt that way too and so new and old friends (and sometime foes) will play more.

And DDS I still your sword joke was one that made me laugh the most ever (just can't remember which game it was in now) so make a comeback please.

Look. This is part of the fun. EW and Max could have been scum. And rest who follows you on lynching EW and Max is equaly wrong.

Max was too silent. I hope he posts more in the next game and i hope the GC chat guys will be back. Maybye even with more

Also DDS could host a game? That thing game he hosted a while back was the bomb.

I'm just saying The logic on me being scum was mostly "1/9 is too low of a chance to know that Rag also visited Halrob". I feel like everything else about how I played it was then not taken into consideration. With how I kept townreading Loose and with how you hard defended me too earlier in the day, I was astounded at how people trusted you over both me and rag.

by **SoN!c** on Thu Oct 02, 2025 1:55 pm

Extreme Ways wrote:
chanakam2020 wrote:
Loose Canon wrote:Just quickly it would have taken quite some in-game persuasion for me
to not have thought king was SK and Devante was not mafia.
Rags thoughts would have been virtually disregarded.

With 3 or 4 players left including me, but in belief there was a mafia and sk left I would have gone no lynch - very very likely.

I was undecided whether to post my suspicions D5 if I lived.
I'd have been confused if I'd lived into D5.

My D4 non posting of suspicions was designed in an ideal world to get mafia and sk to kill each other n4 or if I was killed so 2t Vs 1 other, 2t remaining would have challenge and fun of trying to work out.

mafia and sk to kill each other is not working as this SK is bullet proof one who got immunity from night kills.
Only way to kill the "Bulletproof Serial Killer Multitasking Role Cop" is day lynching.

It's close to a setup I have played before. 3 town PRs, 2 secret town backups. 3 mafia (1 rolecop, 1 vote negator, backup) and 1 werewolf with very similar abilities. The sk being strong is probably balanced by the rolecop there.

But well, mafia had plenty chances to get rid of the sk and I you thought he was a sk too... Sonic wanted Ragian/Sonic resolved first, Loose wanted me resolved first, and mafia were mostly following those two. I had pointed out that the pressure on Kingm died for no apparent reason other than "eh, not feeling like it" and nobody reapplied pressure.

Also yeah, not on Rag. Living players should not communicate with the dead in any way. What if Rag didn't know who was scum? It's still an issue. What if I wasn't spoiled? I would still have said to kill Sonic and Kingm with fire (at the time I thought kingm was a mafia too).

I want to reiterate that lynching outside of pr claims is almost always bad. I wasn't saying that because I was one, it's because the killing factions will want to remove the power that they bring. If we lynch, say, Max instead of me you still mislynch but then mafia and sk have to make choices on whom to roleblock and kill. Especially with a doc claim. We now got a cop result on Loose, otherwise we would also have a tracker result on someone.

Fun game, probably one of the more fun in times. Thanks for hosting Charle.

I agree, but with just 2 goons and 1 roleblock (who was caught D2) mafia needed the SK kills badly...
and as mafia with 2 goons i could not believe all this heavy PR on the other sides

by **Extreme Ways** on Thu Oct 02, 2025 3:43 pm

Rolecop and/or non-consecutive Mafia Doctor would work
Or Rolecop and 1x Strongman (pierces through protects)

by **Extreme Ways** on Thu Oct 02, 2025 3:43 pm

Extreme Ways wrote:Rolecop and/or non-consecutive Mafia Doctor would work
Or Rolecop and 1x Strongman (pierces through protects)

Or at least a backup for the roleblock.

by **SoN!c** on Thu Oct 02, 2025 3:59 pm

Extreme Ways wrote:
Extreme Ways wrote:Rolecop and/or non-consecutive Mafia Doctor would work
Or Rolecop and 1x Strongman (pierces through protects)

Or at least a backup for the roleblock.

Yes it was like a game designed to hang mafia high and dry from the start with just 2 goons but we made it fun and interesting! Im very proud on our play 8-)

by **SoN!c** on Thu Oct 02, 2025 4:12 pm

If you'd think about it: 2 goons and 1 roleblock versus TOWN with 1 JAILKEEPER, 1 COP, 1 DOC and 1 TRACKER and a SK that is unkillable at night wth bodyarmour and who has extra cop next to kill ability each night....

WE MAFIA GOT BAMBOOZLED!

by **SoN!c** on Thu Oct 02, 2025 4:14 pm

"Bamboozled" means to be tricked, deceived, or confused, often by means of trickery, flattery, or misdirection. It can describe the act of hoodwinking someone into a situation, or it can be a state of being thoroughly perplexed or mystified.

by **hjelp** on Thu Oct 02, 2025 5:30 pm

I intended to go all in to lynch Kingm the next day if I survived one more day and Kingm knew that (I think).

by **DirtyDishSoap** on Thu Oct 02, 2025 5:32 pm

Extreme Ways wrote:Also yeah, not on Rag. Living players should not communicate with the dead in any way. What if Rag didn't know who was scum? It's still an issue. What if I wasn't spoiled? I would still have said to kill Sonic and Kingm with fire (at the time I thought kingm was a mafia too).

This. Listen, I'm not trying to be an asshole here, but this is a pretty basic rule and it's typically taboo if you break it. Other sites would outright ban you from playing if you broke it. That goes for the AI too.

Edit - I truly believe that AI post influenced the game for the worst. I seriously would have considered of just washing this game clean and start over, that's just me though. I know I'm ragging on something that happened awhile ago, but that to me is pretty damn egregious.

If you're dead, it's typically fine to talk about it with other dead folks unless it's somehow a conflict of interest or just a rule stated by the host.

You'd have to do some hard convincing on me to play or host again. Folks really need to kick some of these aforementioned bad habits immediately, and also the activity needs more of a pulse. Until these two conditions are met, i really doubt I'm playing again or until a new generation of players comes in.

by **SoN!c** on Thu Oct 02, 2025 6:14 pm

hjelp wrote:I intended to go all in to lynch Kingm the next day if I survived one more day and Kingm knew that (I think).

Yes it was very obvious that Kingm killed you but mafia could not say anything.. like "i know kingm is SK" hmmmmm.

Town should have noticed that on their own