Braveheart Mafia Game thread- MAFIA WIN!!!

[Huckleberryhound]

I was thinking that perhaps the hidden vote was placed earlier in the counting, and not revealed until the lynch occured. Is this possible?

entirely possible.
Jnd's accounting has been questionable at times, with a couple of his posts including double votes. there were 9 votes, and he only counted 8 (no offence Jnd).

It was obvious that yours was the hammer blow, and mine the 9th, but why would i put my neck on the line if i didn't need to ?

[Serbia]

Well good point... unless you felt you had to, because you said you would anyway.

[Huckleberryhound]

Well good point... unless you felt you had to, because you said you would anyway.

6/8 votes. Why would i say i would drop the hammer after a 7th vote if i knew i could double vote ?

[Serbia]

who knows? to try to frame someone? like I said, this isn't solid enough to vote you on, just a theory I had, and it doesn't hold.

[Huckleberryhound]

who knows? to try to frame someone? like I said, this isn't solid enough to vote you on, just a theory I had, and it doesn't hold.

Fair enough mate.

[jnd94]

I was thinking that perhaps the hidden vote was placed earlier in the counting, and not revealed until the lynch occured. Is this possible?

entirely possible.
Jnd's accounting has been questionable at times, with a couple of his posts including double votes. there were 9 votes, and he only counted 8 (no offence Jnd).

It was obvious that yours was the hammer blow, and mine the 9th, but why would i put my neck on the line if i didn't need to ?

none taken. I suck at that.

[Koesen]

Regardless of whose vote actually ended up killing Fircoal, my main problem is that it looks like HBH intended to hammer him without giving him a chance to claim.

Regardless of what happened, it's that intention that looks scummy to me.

I'm still not completely sure of HBH, but for now I'm keeping my vote on him.

[ga7]

Correct me if I'm wrong, but aren't double voters always town?
In any case the final votes were weird sure, and there's certainly scum in the wagon, but it's not like they'd only vote at the end

The little thing between GT and Skittles is interesting. I'll FOS both, Skittles seem to try and stay out of trouble as much as possible; GT, since Skittles didn't vote Fir your first reason is bogus, but well. I'll ask one thing though, don't answer it if you don't want: are you talking about a possibility or you're sure of it?

[Skittles!]

Correct me if I'm wrong, but aren't double voters always town?
In any case the final votes were weird sure, and there's certainly scum in the wagon, but it's not like they'd only vote at the end

The little thing between GT and Skittles is interesting. I'll FOS both, Skittles seem to try and stay out of trouble as much as possible; GT, since Skittles didn't vote Fir your first reason is bogus, but well. I'll ask one thing though, don't answer it if you don't want: are you talking about a possibility or you're sure of it?

How does it seem like I'm trying to stay out as trouble?

[ga7]

Well I won't put a quote recollection but it's been twice you try to put the focus on people not very active. And your vote on Mandy on day 1 was when his wagon had died out. Your general behavior makes me think of a careful scum.

[nagerous]

vote huckleberryhound I have an inkling that he is scum, not just because of the hammer incident but because of his link with skittles, which is linked to why there was no kill last night.

[Huckleberryhound]

[Serbia]

vote huckleberryhound I have an inkling that he is scum, not just because of the hammer incident but because of his link with skittles, which is linked to why there was no kill last night.

I would like to see the explaination there.

[Huckleberryhound]

vote huckleberryhound I have an inkling that he is scum, not just because of the hammer incident but because of his link with skittles, which is linked to why there was no kill last night.

I would like to see the explaination there.

What, from me ?

[Serbia]

no, from nag

[nagerous]

also for what its worth...id be willing to bet i know why the scum failed last night....and it probably wasnt a doc.

this is good evidence I think serbia. I added up a few things and am guessing that something happened in the night involving skittles hence resulting in the no kill at night. Also, skittles and huckleberry have both have had pressure but neither have voted for each other and they've defended one another. This comes across as suspicious.

[Serbia]

You have to admit you're not really giving us anything to go on.

[nagerous]

no better leads at the moment, would you rather no lynch?

[Huckleberryhound]

no better leads at the moment, would you rather no lynch?

And can we count you as scum tomorrow ?

You're really pushing with no evidence. I voted Tonka, and now you think i'm scum because i didn't change my vote to Skittles......Doesn't really make a lot of sense fella.

[nagerous]

I have several theories, none of them confirmed with absolute certainty. If that makes you dislike me, fair enough.

to keep it as simple as possible....it was my formal request to make sure some day vig doesnt commit some egregious sin by killing me.

exactly huck why did you vote tonka, his message was perfectly simple and clear with a reference to sherwood

[Serbia]

no better leads at the moment, would you rather no lynch?

who's suggesting that? scumtell there?

[Skittles!]

I've had no reason to vote for HuckleberryHound.. I didn't ever think he meant to hammer in the first place.

Ga7.. What's scummy about voting Mandy after his bandwagon died out? I still don't get it.. I didn't join the bandwagon, which mafia would obviously had done. Not joining the bandwagon would prove I'm less scummy than people that went onto Fircoal.

[Talapus]

I've had no reason to vote for HuckleberryHound.. I didn't ever think he meant to hammer in the first place.

Ga7.. What's scummy about voting Mandy after his bandwagon died out? I still don't get it.. I didn't join the bandwagon, which mafia would obviously had done. Not joining the bandwagon would prove I'm less scummy than people that went onto Fircoal.

This is a very valid point. In smaller mafia games such as this one, scum would love to bandwagon because the odds will be more in their favor. I'm not defending skittles!, just agreeing at this point. As for who looks scummy at this point , I'm really at a loss.

I still understand the reasoning behind wanting to vote Huck, but don't really agree with it to the point I'll vote that way. And as for the skittles! thing...Well, it's kind of a nice point, but not a valid enough point to earn a vote. So for now, FOS skittles!

[Huckleberryhound]

If i was to change my vote atall, it'd be to some of the lame bandwagoning against me...and i can just guess how that'd be turned around

[Skittles!]

I've had no reason to vote for HuckleberryHound.. I didn't ever think he meant to hammer in the first place.

Ga7.. What's scummy about voting Mandy after his bandwagon died out? I still don't get it.. I didn't join the bandwagon, which mafia would obviously had done. Not joining the bandwagon would prove I'm less scummy than people that went onto Fircoal.

This is a very valid point. In smaller mafia games such as this one, scum would love to bandwagon because the odds will be more in their favor. I'm not defending skittles!, just agreeing at this point. As for who looks scummy at this point , I'm really at a loss.

I still understand the reasoning behind wanting to vote Huck, but don't really agree with it to the point I'll vote that way. And as for the skittles! thing...Well, it's kind of a nice point, but not a valid enough point to earn a vote. So for now, FOS skittles!

Whaa? You agree with me, yet still FOS me because people believe I have a possible link with HBH..

Okay, for what Nag said. We've both had pressure, yes, but why vote for each other? I haven't seen any real evidence against HBH, just random speculations against both of us.

Why would there be a link with me and HBH and the no kill last night? I really don't get that.